Tag Archives: fossil fuel divesting

Fossil Fuel Divestment Just Got A Whole Lot Easier

I spend a lot of time talking to people about divesting from fossil fuels – family members, friends, people at meetings and seminars – and the occasional random person who makes the mistake of asking what I do.  Most of these people are really concerned about climate change.  Its inspiring to hear that many have taken steps to reduce their carbon footprints. But, only a few people bring up that they’ve divested their investments from fossil fuels.

One problem is that the idea is only a couple of years old. Whether you have a few bucks tucked away for retirement or you’re a Shark Tank gazillionaire, there’s a 99% chance that your investments didn’t come to mind when you first started wondering about things you might do to help slow down global warming.

If you have heard about divestment, there’s also a 99% chance you heard that divestment flies in the face of conventional “wisdom” when it comes to investing. The pivotal barrier is the idea that there are supposedly only a few reinvestment options that are fossil fuel free.  And, by extension, that means that divesting is a financially risky thing to do. Here again, one problem is that the idea is new and any information hasn’t penetrated very far. The second problem is that, to the degree that there is discussion of divestment, much of the thinking is muddled or just plain wrong. Kind of like listening to Donald Trump talking about – well – just about anything.

A new website from the non-profit As You Sow will be a potent weapon in knocking this barrier down. Why?  Because, in a few seconds, you can check to see if a mutual fund has investments in the fossil fuel industry or not.

The goal of the divestment movement is to pull support away from the major fossil fuel companies and shine a big bright light on the nonexistent (or, depending on the country, woefully ineffective or just stupid) policy response to climate change. The tool’s “Carbon Underground 200” screening option allows you to see if your fund holds stock in the companies at global warming’s ground zero. The website also instantly lets people see that many diversified small-cap funds, many sector funds, and a whole bunch of other funds don’t hold these stocks.  Depending on how far future improvements go, the site will also eventually demonstrate that small and mid-cap exchange traded funds (ETFs) and many other mutual funds are inherently fossil fuel free.

Fund holdings information has always been publicly available, but few people are geeky enough to hunt for it. (Guilty as charged.) In the long run, the game changer here is that this tool completely blows up the notion that if you want to divest, you only have a few options. That includes many funds already available in company 401k plans.

Its important to point out that a leading group of forward-thinking investment companies were way ahead of the curve and created funds that are fully fossil fuel free by design, As divestment grows in popularity, the website will help get the word out about these funds, too.

What’s new here is that this tool makes it clear that the set of fossil free investment options is big.  Very big. And, that will draw a lot more people to the idea. The power of personal divestment is in the number of people who take the leap. For this side of the divestment movement to make a difference, we need people to divest and we need them ASAP.

Andy Behar and the smart, inspired people of As You Sow (and their partners) have just fired off the 21st century “click heard ’round the world.”  Thank you folks – nicely done.  (Wouldn’t it be great to see Steven Colbert, Bill McKibben and Andy checking out the site….Steven – you there?)

Fossil Fuel Divestment – An Easy First Step For Individuals

The post on October 18 talked about the hypothetical impact of removing fossil  fuel investments from broadly diversified mutual or exchange traded funds. When taking money out of any single industry, whether the unwelcome stocks are in fossil fuels or mass media or donuts, it is hard to argue that extracting investments from a single industry will have a measurable effect on long-term fund performance. Diversification means that the sensitivity to whatever happens in any one industry is going to be very low.

The practical question then is this – how can an individual divestor who wants to be in diversified funds take this idea and do something with it? You can’t tell a mutual fund company “I’d really like to invest in your XYZ fund – except, can you take out the fossil fuel companies?”

In fact, there are many, many ways for an investor to move into these waters. And, there’s one easy place to start.

The most straightforward first move is to reinvest freed up money into diversified small or mid-cap Exchange Traded Funds (ETFs), or small-cap mutual funds. (“Cap” is short for capitalization – the dollar figure you get when you multiply the number of company shares by the share price. There’s no standard designations, but large usually means a capitalization greater than $10B, mid cap is between $2B-$10B and small cap is below $2B.)  There are also a few funds that are specifically designed to exclude fossil fuel companies.

The major players in the fossil fuel business are big – really big. ExxonMobil’s market cap is currently about $400B. By putting your money into small and mid cap funds, you can avoid investing in these stocks. Stocks that are at ground zero when it comes to global warming since they are issued by the largest companies that find and sell fossil fuels. There are a lot of diversified small and mid-cap funds to pick from – both approaches are bread-and-butter offerings for many fund companies. (Note that a mid-cap mutual fund is fairly likely to hold some large cap companies, so an easy way to have a diversified position in mid-cap stocks would be with a mid-cap ETF.)

Investments are bets. And, so the natural next question is what bet is an investor making when using this approach?

Interestingly, a common conclusion of comparisons between mid or small cap stocks versus large cap stocks is that both tend to outperform large cap stocks (while both tend to be more volatile). Take a look at two example discussions from CNBC/Yahoo Finance: one and two.

Take a few minutes and look around for yourself. There are a lot of articles on these comparisons, particularly the small-large cap version. Most brokerage sites and personal finance sites have areas where you can compare small, medium and large cap funds for yourself. You can also look at the historical performance of market indexes that track different market cap stocks. Keeping with the diversification theme, the most meaningful comparison would be a combination of small and mid cap funds versus large cap funds, since a diversified investment approach would probably mean you’ll hold both types.

So, what’s the takeaway from all this? It’s a virtual certainty that people and the planet are in big trouble if we don’t massively curb the burning of fossil fuels. As we do that the value of the traditional fossil fuel companies will fall.  On the flip side, it would be reasonable to think that diversified small and mid-cap funds will hold up well against their large cap brethren over the long haul.  (Also, keep in mind this is just one of many reinvestment possibilities an investor  can follow – including supporting the growth of the new energy economy by investing in funds that tie to that theme or investing in fully fossil free funds.)

Many investment advisors make the point that your investment decisions should allow you to sleep at night. Will betting against the planet and your kids’ future keep you up at night?  Think about it.